Your ideas and suggestions

WebBall Community Pages on WebBall with ideas shared by many contributors within our community may not always credit individuals but they do show the power of the community as a whole to express opinions and, we hope, sway decisions. These pages also allow WebBall members to post additional comments directly. (Click to close.)
This page is an experiment; our version of a discussion forum where we welcome new ideas and reader comments on anything to do with hitting. You must be a registered WebBall member or subscriber to contribute. Basic rules of netiquette apply and anyone found to be abusing the privilege may have his/her membership revoked.
The dialog is monitored and if we identify topics that need to be explored in greater depth we will put our main site resources into action.
Andy Tkachyk says:
Jul 06, 2008 at 12:41 AM
We have a player who has
A - Little or no hip rotation in his swing.
B - Scrunches his shoulders up and never really gets full extension on
his swing.
I feel that a causes b to happen.
Because he only has his upper body functioning he's working twice as hard to get the upper body rotating.
I'm getting him to work on his hip explosion, which i feel will make it easier to work on getting the upper body hands drive the butt of the bat at the ball and make getting to full
extension
Our other coach is working on his upper body mechanics first. I know both a and b have to be corrected. But is it not better to correct a then move onto b. Don't want to confuse the kid. What do you think?
Richard Todd says:
Jul 11, 2008 at 8:57 AM
I would be inclined to work on A first. But I also work with a hitting coach who I'm certain would be more about hands and upper body drive.
Sometimes it comes down to which way a player will learn best - and unfortunately you can't know that until you try.
That's not a cop out (well maybe it is) but that's why I want to leave this question posted here - to see what other comments we receive over time.